Dove Shine A Light
Jonathan Dove talks candidly about his music and his world
On Saturday 15th March, the William Byrd Singers will give a concert featuring, alongside works by Poulenc, Tallis, and others, no fewer than three pieces by genuinely-still-alive composer and all-round genial fellow Jonathan Dove. Not wishing to miss this opportunity to speak with the creative artists whose work we perform [An awful shame when we missed that chance to interview Byrd himself! — Ed.] we asked some questions, and the answers to those questions only triggered more questions.... It became a veritable feast of Dove-inalia! The interview [So formal, it was a conversation, really. — Ed.] is altogether too valuable as a musical resource to make casually available to just anyone. So we've clipped up some highlights, and provided a transcript for the fearless. Read on for more...oh, you've already hit Play. FINE.
Introduction
Hi. I'm Jonathan Dove. I'm a composer, and the wonderful William Byrd Singers are gonna sing some of my music.
What's your earliest musical memory?
My earliest musical memory is my mother playing the piano while the children were drifting off to sleep. So I'm, you know, really just a baby and my parents both worked very hard -- they were architects. But in the evening, to unwind once she had managed to get us into bed, my mother would go and play sometimes Handel's Largo or Debussy's Clair de Lune, I remember or his Arabesque. Bits of Oklahoma. And then the next day I would go to the piano and try and copy the things I had heard her playing. So that was really how it all started. But the thing was just that lovely feeling of connection. That even though there was a very cold passageway between the living room and the bedroom, I was hearing this music. I knew that she was playing.
In this section, we asked Jonathan about his early musical experiences, and which (if any) he considered foundational or which steered him towards the choral music and opera for which he is known.
How were your first encounters with choral music?
I was singing in the church choir when I was maybe 9, but it was a very simple choir, not singing in harmony.Were you a singer?
First, singing at school -- that I remember well, I particularly enjoyed it. Also in secondary schools where I most remember enjoying the singing because then we did sing proper choral music in four parts, and I think I had quite a nice voice as a treble and I remember singing. the Pie Jesu in the Fauré Requiem.Any memorable experiences?
At one point our school choir was affiliated to the Royal School of Church Music and that meant we could take part in sort of massed choral events. I can remember two of those happening, where everyone will be sent in music. So I can't really tell you how many, 30, 40 choirs all joined together. And so from being 20 or 30 people we all suddenly became, you know, a thousand or more. And that was an amazing experience to be in, to learn something, you know: to sing your part and then feel that you are contributing to this enormous sound. And I think that experience led later on to writing community opera and trying to recapture that feeling of singing en masse.
In this section, we asked Jonathan about his early compositional efforts, his first successes, and where he finds the trigger for a piece.
When did you first start writing music?
In my teenage years I was always making up pieces at the piano, but I would never really succeed in writing them down -- or what I was able to write was always much more basic than what I'd been playing. I don't know, I feel inspired at the keyboard [but] learning to write pieces it took-- my sort of journey to becoming a composer, that took quite a while, but I did write a mass I can remember for the church choir. As I recall it was quite jolly, and it was like a sort of tripping 9/8, no 12/8 Gloria. I could probably still remember, but I think it would be too embarrassing. So you know, when years later I came to write a Missa Brevis, I had already had a few goes at writing a mass for a choir.When did you get into opera?
I started when I left university. I started playing the piano for opera rehearsals. And that was when I discovered the whole world of opera, really that. So that was kind of in my early 20s and it was really almost a complete surprise. I mean, I had heard some operas and I had seen one or two, but I'd really not been exposed to it very much. And I couldn't believe how exciting that was and that I was actually getting paid to accompany, you know, amazing singers like James Bowman, their famous counter-tenor. That was a voice that made a big impression on me.When did you write the piece that you thought was strong enough to be published?
Gosh, yes, I did some work for the Salisbury Festival, so I wrote a few pieces, including a choral piece for them. And I was asked, following on from that, to write a choral piece, which is my earliest published choral work, Welcome All Wonders, which is a Christmas piece.Was this when you realised how much the text mattered to you?
And not long after that -- again, it was in connection with Salisbury Cathedral. The presenter asked me to write a substantial piece of music, for an event that was going to involve a choir and dancers and steel pans. And organ. And it seemed like a large piece of music that had to be written quite quickly. And I said, well, it'll depend entirely on how inspiring the words turn out to be. And so he sent me the words, which had-- there's a prayer, the Benedicite, a lot of invocations to bless, but also there were some passages from Genesis. And "in the beginning was the word," there was a phrase I remember about. "And the Spirit of God was moving over the face of the waters." And I found all this music coming, pouring out. And I had no idea, I thought where did all that come from? But I realised that, those images that I had absorbed, you know, before the age of reason, were part of my unconscious and even though I was not a churchgoer and not consciously living any sort of religious life, these words and images and ideas still had enormous power for me, and that was really the beginning of writing church music. And a lot of the choral music I've written has been for church, but not all of it. And I have found that to be a very satisfying place to write about a sense of mystery, a sense of wonder: a sense of awe.
- Missa Brevis
In this section we talk to Jonathan about the Missa Brevis, which we'll be performing.
Early efforts
So before I wrote the Mr Brevis, I'd had a couple of goes at writing a mass, one that very early on that I mentioned when I was a teenager, and then one when I would say that I was pulling nearer to finding my voice as a composer. But it's not a published work. It was a mass for, as I remember it, for two Sopranos. And, and it was that particular church that was the choir they had. And so I had, as it were, made the musical journey through the the Mass, a couple of times. But those are, yeah, as I said, neither of those are published or indeed publishable works.How the piece came about
And then in -- I think it's first performed in 2009, so probably in 2008 -- I was approached by the Cathedral Organist Association to write a Missa Brevis. And Matthew Owens, who's the director of music at Wells Cathedral, and was in charge of the commission, gave me a clear brief, which I cannot right now remember [...] The model probably was the Benjamin Britten Missa Brevis, which I'd grown up with on gramophone record. I don't think I'd ever heard that liturgically at that point. But I liked it and I — you know it moves through the text quite quickly. So that gave me a sense of the sort of scale I suppose.A 'tribal/dance' Gloria
But I enormously enjoyed writing it, and I have a particular fondness for the Gloria, which I feel has this, it's got a feeling of a dance and there's also something maybe a bit tribal. That is sort of everything I would hope that the Gloria could have. I think it may not be the easiest piece in the world, but I think it's a fun -- it's a rhythm that's fun.
- Seek Him that Maketh The Seven Stars
In this section we talk to Jonathan about Seek Him, which we'll be performing.
Seek Him: first anthem
Seek Him that Maketh The Seven Stars is the first anthem that I wrote and from what everyone tells me it is the the work of mine, or would be called certainly anthem of mine that gets sung most often. Was a commission from Saint James's Church in Piccadilly, who had, and perhaps still do have an annual service for artists? And so I'm thinking, well, what words would be suitable for a service for artists, and if it was something to do with light?The quote at the heart of the work
[And it was actually the quotation from Amos -- "Seek Him that maketh the seven stars, and Orion, and turneth the shadow of night into the morning," is that right? I mean, this is a long time, so there's like, 1995, that was 30 years ago I guess I wrote that. Um.] I found that in a an anthology of religious writings that the uncle of a friend had written. So that was just a book that I happened to have called An Anthology of Hope. And I thought, well, that's it. That's to do with light and that that was so that was the connection. And it's interesting that it's probably about the shortest text that I have set for an anthem, but it felt very full and it felt like these were words that you could explore and that would bear repetition and investigation, if you like.Did you know it was good while writing it?
I had no idea that this piece was going to get performed after the premiere, but I was obviously thrilled that it has been. I think I was given very good advice, which was that on this occasion the choir was only going to see it half an hour before the service, but the organist would have time to practise and so I could therefore write a tricky organ part if I wanted. But the voice parts had to be something that, I mean, that the professional singers could sight read because it's a church where there's a small, like 8-part choir, but they're professional singers. And I think just imagining that sort of situation, I think I ended up writing something which was not too difficult for the voices and so I think that has helped. But it obviously I-- because it was my first attempt at writing an anthem, well, I suppose I thought was just, Should I just let my imagination run free? And that's what came out, yeah.
- Praise Him with the Sound of the Trumpet
In this section we talk to Jonathan about Praise Him, which we'll be performing.
The commission
So Praise Him With The Sound Of The Trumpet was written as a birthday present commissioned by Kate [Young]'s parents. And kept a secret from her very skilfully by the choir of Guildford Cathedral, where she is a chorister. So every time that they were going to rehearse it, they had to find some pretext to to have her not be in the rehearsal. And I don't really know how they managed it, but it meant that when the day came she was sight reading, or she maybe saw it in the morning. But [so] it was a wonderful experience, for everyone.
- General questions
Is there a way to tell early Dove from late Dove?
I'm not sure that you can tell which order those pieces are written in just by listening. I think in my operas you can see a development, because different stories make different demands, and one has to find new sounds to convey feelings that one hasn't tried to convey before. But also they're very big canvases, I mean, and you know, an opera might be a couple of hours of music, so there are more telltale signs there. But I think when I, as it were, found my voice as a composer -- I can't really explain it more helpfully, but I feel that they sound like the same composer.
In this section we put to Jonathan questions canvassed from the members of the choir.
Do you approach writing for professionals differently from writing for amateurs?
[Jonathan was advised that he didn't have to answer! -- Ed.]
Well, writing community operas, as I call them, they have been such an important thing for me, and the first three that I wrote I also was the conductor. And also with those first three, there was a collaborative process in writing the piece. So I actually wrote some of the songs I wrote with groups of people who were going to be taking part in the opera. So we kind of, it was co- creation if you like. I think that was a formative experience, 'cause I had a feeling of what ordinary people have in their heads, what kind of music they have in their heads, and they might imagine, but I also discovered quickly what kind of things would be really tricky. And what kind of things might be, as you could call it, expensive in rehearsal time. And so there are some things... no, I don't think singers differ so much from each other, but certainly singers and instrumentalists differ quite a bit, and in particular because instrumentalists are usually playing with the sheet music in front of them. But when you're writing for singers on stage, they've got to memorise everything. And so there are lots of differences in terms of what you think of.Do you have a preference?
[Jonathan was advised that he didn't have to answer! -- Ed.]
I had a sort of Road to Damascus experience that opened up the whole world of community opera to me, which was doing a community opera version of West Side Story, with 200 amateurs in a disused cotton mill in Bradford. And around the same time I was working as assistant chorusmaster at Glyndebourne. So I was going from working with a professional chorus who were fantastic and could do everything to an amateur chorus for whom everything was really new and who had no training at all. But they had this look in their eyes, they were just so excited to be doing this, to be singing this music. And to be allowed to sing this music. And there's also this excitement of doing something that wasn't what they normally did. And maybe something they hadn't even expected to do. And I happen to enjoy both of those enormously. And that has carried on. But that feeling of the hunger and the appetite that an amateur group can have -- it's very special. And the excitement that they had of discovering, wow, we could do that! I didn't know I could sing like that or I didn't know that if I joined forces with other people we could make this sound, that we could do something that I would be proud of. It has felt like, I suppose, the most unquestionably worthwhile thing that I've done. And so I find it enormously satisfying now to find opportunities to bring together professional and amateur because I think both sides gain so much. And I've done that several times in community operas where there are maybe a handful of professional soloists and as many people as we can fit in, which might be hundreds of untrained or at least non- professional singers and I think being next to a professional singer, you know, who spent their whole life training, that's very inspiring. For anyone. But it's also very inspiring for the professional to be reminded of the joy that they felt, you know, that that made them want to be a musician in the first place. But that also applies to instrumentalists working side by side. So that has been a real joy to write works where you can bring all of these together.
How do you balance taking inspiration from other composers without going too far?
Jonathan Dove — in his own words!
Jonathan Dove — in his own words!
I think you can tell from my music, many of the composers that I'm fond of, you could possibly tell any piece of music which I've heard from from it. I always try to avoid actually copying anyone else and particularly because I'm writing essentially tonal music: that there are only, maybe 7 notes in a scale, the chances of accidentally reinventing the wheel are quite high. And every so often I find myself thinking, why is that particular piece of Ravel going round and round in my head today? I think, oh, because I've just written it. And so well, if that happens, then obviously I change it. I think I better have a better idea or just a different idea. But it's something I have to do, I don't worry. There was a moment of illumination when I'm starting out, when I realised that being deep or being original, when things that you could achieve through an effort of will it either you have those things or not. So I thought, well there's no point in worrying about that. I'll just write the music I want to hear, and other people can decide whether it's deep or original.Your harmonies feel quite timeless, yet modern. Where does the inspiration for that soundworld come from?
The feeling of timelessness is something that's certainly very important to me and something I love in great works by other composers. One piece that I hope I haven't copied, but I think of having that is actually Stravinsky's Symphony of Psalms, in the last movement. You just have to listen to it to to find that which is...it seems to be music, music from space sounds too glib, that's not quite what I mean, and just, just to listen to it. Arvo Pärt I feel has that quality very much and it's new music, but also feels like it connects to mediaeval music and so it's new and yet old at the same time. Those are, yeah, those are the first two things that spring to mind.Many contemporary works need patient listening before they can be understood. What do you hope for in an audience's reaction to hearing your work for the first time?
I hope to write music that needs no introduction, music that you don't have to do any homework before you hear it. And I want people -- I mean, this is about opera particularly -- I want them to be able to hear every word. And to get what's happening first time, because there may well not be a second time, you know, it's expensive to go to the opera. So certainly I want -- I hope -- the audience is going to connect with the music straight away. I don't want it to feel difficult for them. I don't mind if it's difficult for the performers or that they have to practise a bit. But I don't want it to be a struggle to listen to. Uh. And obviously, particularly with the pieces that we're talking about, I hope that people feel transported or, you know, carried away somewhere, yeah.Any advice for young composers?
I've been asked that lots of times. The most helpful thing I could say to you young composers is: just write the music you want to hear. And in my experience, it's very easy to worry about what other people are going to think, but actually, if you can, probably your hardest critic will be yourself. So if you can actually satisfy yourself, if you can get it good enough, a piece that you're imagining, to please yourself...probably other people will enjoy it too. Maybe not all of them, but enough.
Quickfire questions
In this section, we put to Jonathan some questions that have divided the nation and caused wars, in the hope that he may dispense some ancient compositional wisdom and soothe troubled waters. [Spoiler: he does not. -- Ed.]
Quickfire section!
CATS OR DOGS? I grew up with cats, but actually probably nowadays I prefer dogs. STILTON OR BRIE? Both. LENNON OR MCCARTNEY? Go with with Paul McCartney for longevity. BACH OR HANDEL? Oh God, that's hard. I -- yeah, I want both. BYRD OR TALLIS? So that is a long answer for me because the church to which I wheel my father has a strong association with Thomas Tallis. And yet they do often sing Byrd masses in this church. Yeah, you've gotta have both. GILBERT OR SULLIVAN? Actually, one without the other you're really lost. MARMITE, Y/N? Yeah. EARL GREY OR LAPSAANG? Earl Grey. JAM OR CREAM FIRST? Yeah, cream I think works better. SCON(E) OR SCO(H)NE? Scon(e).
Wrapping Up
Our huge thanks to Jonathan for agreeing to this, for persevering with the format, questions, and technology despite their many horrors, and for unfailing charm and good humour throughout. His efforts to make the choir members' questions appear intelligent and insightful have not gone unnoticed! Our thanks also to choir members Andrew and Rob, for organising and digitising, respectively, and to our Editor [This is the kind of recognition I crave. -- Ed.] The latter agonised over cuts, and assures us that any infelicities that remain in the video clips or transcripts are his cross to bear alone. [Such fortitude! --Ed.] Thanks to Byrds Clare, Anne, Rachel, Andrew, Rob, and Agnes for their questions.
And if you've got all the way through that, you are now primed and ready to attend the concert!. Once again, it's Shine Through The Darkness, 1900 on Saturday 14th March at Christ Church West Didsbury. We hope to see you there!

